Undocumented immigrants’ children born in the US have become Trump’s latest foe. He does not believe that these US children hold valid citizenship despite the fact that since they were born in the US they receive citizenship automatically, a right granted by the 14th Amendment of the Constitution.
I don’t think they have American citizenship and if you speak to some very, very good lawyers — and I know some will disagree — but many of them agree with me and you’re going to find they do not have American citizenship.
In his usual rambling manner, he does not name any of the “very, very good lawyers” nor does he elaborate his reasons for saying that these children are not US citizens by birth. Trump is not one to quibble over “details”: The children are not citizens because he says so, because the “incompetent idiots in Washington are wrong” as always.
An article in the Washington Post outlines the flaws in Trump’s proposal:
He leaves out what is perhaps the most important detail: Such change would be very difficult as it would require the repeal of the 14th Amendment, which would take require the approval of 75 percent (or 38) of the state legislatures, an unlikely event. There have been 11,000 attempts to amend the Constitution in the entire history of the United States, and only 27 succeeded.
Even Trump sycophant Ted Cruz admits the difficulty of changing Constitutional amendments. According to birthright supporters, ending it would have catastrophic consequences:
Supporters of birthright citizenship say there are a number of reasons it should be maintained. It’s part of the Constitution. Attempts to restrict it have historically been motivated by racist fears of immigrants and their children. Ending it would be a bureaucratic nightmare. The most extreme consequence would be a massive group of stateless people — neither citizens in the U.S. nor in foreign countries.
These warnings do not seem to have much on an impact on other Republicans, particularly the candidates for the Presidential nomination:
This week, several of Mr. Trump’s Republican rivals, including Gov. Scott Walker of Wisconsin, echoed his call to end automatic citizenship for the American-born children of undocumented immigrants, repealing a constitutional right dating from the Civil War era.
Public opinion about birthright citizenship is mixed. A Wall Street Journal /NBC poll found that 43% of Republicans in the sample said that the U.S. should work to find and deport people who have come to the U.S. illegally. However, a survey of a sample of 2,002 adults conducted by the Pew Research Center in May, 2015, found that 72 percent of respondents believed that
Undocumented immigrants currently living in the U.S. should be allowed to stay in the country legally, if certain requirements are met.
Public opinion may be divided, but the effects of the anti-birthright campaign have been dire. Some children in Texas are unable to secure the birth certificates they need to enroll in school:
At issue is the health service agency’s Vital Statics Unit, which is responsible for issuing birth certificates, and its refusal to honor various foreign identifications from immigrant parents. Many Mexican immigrants receive identification cards commonly known as matriculas, which are issued by Mexican consulates to citizens living and working in the United States. But officials [in Texas] have increasingly come to refuse these, making it harder for parents living in the U.S. illegally to obtain birth certificates for their children.
To sum up: Trump is stirring up more anti-undocumented immigrant rhetoric through an attack against a Constitutionally-given right, birthright US citizenship. Trump, always the sophist, contends that children of undocumented immigrant born in the US were never citizens, an idea he claims is supported by “very good lawyers,” whom he fails to identify.
In fact, the only way to eliminate birthright citizenship is to repeal the 14th Amendment of the Constitution, something practically impossible because bringing about such repeals are very difficult, as shown by thousands of attempts have failed in the past. The “bottom line” is that Trump is stirring up a controversy that has no practical purpose. The only result is that undocumented parents find it very difficult to obtain the birth certificates their children need to enroll in school. How Trumplike: Being a loose cannon and disregarding its consequences.
The social construction of “citizenship” is one of the most fundamentally inhumane concepts invented in my own humble opinion…and while I think the republican party needs to be abolished for too many reasons to list here (forefront reason being no political party that does not reflect the larger national demographics should be allowed to rule, etc.) along with other institutions, etc., that either violate, or are in favor of, violating human rights, the republican party should look to Reagan and remember some of the notable things (even if few) he did do that was actually good, such as granting amnesty to several million undocumented human beings in the U.S. But the concept of amnesty does not seem to be in the minds or even vocabulary of these folks. I think anybody who holds those sentiments should have to trade shoes with an undocumented person/family for an appreciable period of time–quite literally…and perhaps study an honest history of the U.S., etc., etc. ugh. I think my teenage daughter summed up Trump in a very short quote while squirming and her skin crawling, “Donald Trump is so GROSS!” followed with wanting to move out of the U.S. if he becomes president with her biggest issue related to the anti-immigrant trash he’s been spewing for a very long time now. As a very bright first generation young man, family now in both the U.S. and Mexico, once asked, “Why is it that the U.S. wanted the Berlin Wall broken down but wants to put one up between the U.S. and Mexico?”…. What to say….